Soft Market, Solid Bargains
These
days, it seems like everyone — TV pundits,
wannabe presidential candidates and even the guy next door — has
something to say about how bad the economy is getting.
For some boat buyers, however, the present economic conditions
have a silver lining. Now could be one of the best times in
years to find great deals on new 2008 and even leftover 2007
models sitting in dealer showrooms.
To say that boat dealers are eager to get rid of their inventory
is an understatement. In November 2007 alone, at the lead-up
to the winter boat show season when traditionally almost half
of new boats are purchased, sales of fiberglass boats were
20% lower than the previous year, according to industry analysts.
Boat sales for all of 2007 are expected to be 10% lower than
in 2006. Brunswick, owner of Bayliner and Sea Ray boats among
others, announced that, in terms of unit sales, it was their
weakest year since 1965. And in 2006, sales were 5% lower than
2005.
Deals on boat loans may also be possible. As this issue of
BoatU.S. Magazine went to press, the Federal Reserve had just
cut interest rates to stimulate consumer spending. While there
is some question about whether this move will really benefit
the economy because it can lead to inflation, there is no doubt
that it presents short-term benefits for anyone who can afford
to take on some additional debt.
The used boat market for several years now has been favoring
both current owners who want to upgrade and novices hoping
to enter the field. Used boats accounted for 72% of all vessels
sold in 2006. Again, analysts are predicting this trend will
continue. Why is this perfect economic storm hitting the marine
industry?
Well, a recession is looming, troubled housing and credit
markets are sapping consumer buying power and the cost of the
petroleum products used to build and propel fiberglass boats
has skyrocketed in the past year. How the industry weathers
the storm and how well boat owners keep the faith could affect
boating for years to come.
A recession is defined as six months of reduced or constricted
economic activity. Many economists predict that the nation
as a whole is headed for recession in 2008, but the marine
industry has been slogging through its own private recession
for the past year. There is little indication that things will
change anytime soon.
Headlines
in the boating press during 2007 reflected the grim reality: “Boat Repossessions on Rise in the Rust
Belt,” “Flat Is The New Up,” “Anxious
Industry Hopes for Strong Lauderdale Show,” “2006
Fuel-Price Spiral Left Its Scars on Industry.”
Signs of
growing turbulence were common throughout 2007. Some boatbuilders — even major players like Brunswick
and Genmar — laid off workers because declines in boat
sales reduced the demand for new product. Manufacturing plants
were closed or moved to areas — sometimes outside the
U.S. — where labor rates and the cost of doing business
were lower.
As if that’s not enough bad news, Bank of America Securities
analysts weighed in last fall with, “Factors such as
the housing slowdown, increased incidents of mortgage defaults,
growth in the used boat market and low consumer sentiment are
affecting the overall marine industry.
“The current expectation in 2007 for industry boat
retail sales is roughly 260,000 units, which is below the lowest
level of 277,000 units in the early 1990s, and 11% less than
the 296,000 units sold in 2003, the last trough year,” Bank
of America reported.
According
to statistics published by the National Marine Manufacturers
Association (NMMA), the industry typically operates in a
five-year cycle of three “up” years and two “down” years.
However, the most recent cycle was three down years and two
up years. A bit of marine industry history helps to put the
present situation in perspective.
The last major recession to hit the marine industry occurred
in the late 1980s and lasted through the early 1990s. At the
time, the industry looked very different, populated as it was
by conglomerates Brunswick, Genmar, Tracker Marine and Outboard
Marine Corporation (OMC). Many small, independently owned boatbuilders
filed for bankruptcy. Other small independents, like Cobalt,
Grady-White and Catalina Yachts, rode out the bad times through
a combination of consistent product quality and creative responses
to dealer and consumer needs.
As the recession waned, Brunswick, Genmar and OMC strengthened
by buying up boat makes so their product lines cover the gamut
of low, middle and luxury fishing boats, runabouts and cruisers.
Rather than trying to perfect the niche market, the thinking
was that the conglomerates could offer something to appeal
to every boat buyer.
OMC went bankrupt and disappeared from the scene in 2000,
but Genmar and Brunswick, along with Tracker, remain dominant.
A few smaller conglomerates have formed: American Marine Holding
(Donzi and Pro-Line), Luhrs Marine Group (Luhrs, Hunter, Mainship
and Silverton) among them. In addition, many independent builders
have allied into buying groups to take advantage of the kinds
of discounts available only to the likes of Brunswick.
So, is the industry healthier going into this latest recession?
Lessons learned the hard way during the early 1990s recession
include the importance of diversity in product lines, consolidation
of physical plants and cost-cutting measures like group purchasing
power and even overseas production. American builders are also
exporting more boats than ever before, a trend that will probably
continue as the dollar weakens against foreign currency.
Along the way, the marine industry in general has revamped
its customer service philosophy as a way to build loyalty and
a repeat customer base.
Positive
change is most evident where consumers experience the lion’s share of their contact with the industry:
at the retail level with their local boat dealerships and repair
yards. Intense effort has been made to give customers what
they want and this largely mirrors what they’ve come
to expect from auto dealerships: stem to stern service.
NMMA has responded by creating a dealer certification program
and many forward-thinking dealers are using successful customer
service models based on how auto dealers do business. Multi-site
organizations like Westrec-owned marinas, which are found worldwide,
Marine Max, with 85 locations throughout the U.S., and Passport
Marine, with 10 locations along the East Coast, cover every
aspect of boat ownership, from financing to one-on-one training,
storage, repair and boat transport.
Consumers
are, of course, being hit by the same economic hardships
faced by the industry. But, one segment that may not be feeling
the pinch are baby boomers whose kids are grown and whose
mortgages are all but paid off. That second home or a larger
boat may be within reach. For these folks, this could be
the year to sail away.
(c)
Copyright BoatU.S. Magazine, March 2008
|